When judging conformation, sometimes the top horse will be the most obvious, but if not, I may reverse the process and start with identifying which horse in the class shows the least positives. That was the case with this class of young reining mares. The first and second-place mares were more difficult to separate than the second and third-place pair, so I determined my third-place horse first. Then I looked carefully at my top two and applied the judging criteria of balance, structural correctness, breed and sex characteristics, and muscling.  The first and second-place mares are alike in many positive traits, but also enough different that the first-place mare became clear. Her balance and structure are just a bit better than the second-place mare, and since they are mares, I considered how feminine they appear, which falls under the breed and sex characteristics category. Among the considerations for judges of conformation is preserving breed type, so I select horses that come closest to that ideal.

Can you place this class? Study each mare below — click any photo to enlarge it for a closer look. Then use the 1st / 2nd / 3rd buttons (or drag a photo up to your scorecard) to place the class. Submit to see your score and the judge’s full reasoning.

Your Placing
The Lineup — study each mare
Your Score

How the Judge Approached This Class
Judge’s Commentary
Official Placing
The Judge’s Reasoning — Mare by Mare
GET FREE UNLIMITED ACCESS

Register today and get FREE unlimited access to all content from Horse&Rider!

RELATED
Learn to Listen
Are You Really Listening to Your Horse?
Say No to Hair Breakage!
The Science Behind Horse Conditioning Sprays and Detanglers 
A Breath of Fresh Air
How to Choose Respiratory Support for Your Horse
Smoky Condition Know-How
Wildfire Smoke and Your Horse's Health
How hot is too hot?
Is It Too Hot to Ride?
Listen to Your Horse
Is Your Horse Hurting?
Topics
Tags